In 1960, Randolph A. Hearst and his brother William R. Hearst, Jr. named the first program judges. The judges are professional journalists/editors whose valuable time and talents are generously volunteered to the program each year. Over the course of their three-year terms, they judge the work of thousands of students across the country. Judges are sent the entry materials and rate the work based on a point system. The assigned points are then sent to the Foundation where they're compiled and the students are ranked and notified of their placements. The following is the list of judges who evaluate the monthly and Championship entries in the writing, photojournalism, television, radio, and multimedia competitions of the 2012-2013 Hearst Journalism Awards Program. The program thanks the judges for this immeasurable contribution to the future of journalism.
| Writing Competitions | Affiliation |
| Ward Bushee, Executive Vice President & Editor | The San Francisco Chronicle, CA |
| Marty Kaiser, Editor and Senior Vice President | Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Milwaukee, WI |
| John Temple, Managing Editor | The Washington Post, DC |
| Photojournalism Competitions | Affiliation |
| Steve Gonzales, Director of Photography | Houston Chronicle, Houston, TX |
| Sue Morrow, Assistant Multimedia Editor | Sacramento Bee , CA |
| Jakub Mosur, Freelance Photographer | San Francisco, CA |
| Broadcast News Competitions | Affiliation |
| Edward L. Esposito, VP, Information Media | Rubber City Radio Group, Akron, OH |
| Kate O'Brian, Senior Vice President | ABC News, New York, NY |
| Fred Young, retired Senior Vice President for News | Hearst Television Inc., New York, NY |
| Multimedia Competitions | Affiliation |
| Cory Tolbert Haik, Executive Producer for Digital News | The Washington Post , Washington, DC |
| Rotation of judges from other disciplines | |

